Mission Statement

About the ACRU

In the Courts

ACRU Courtwatch

In the News

More ACLU Outrages

Other Resources

Support the ACRU

Search the Site

Contact Us

 

 

Issue: First Amendment

Summary

The First Amendment to the Constitution states that “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press, or of the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.”

These fundamental rights are under siege. Today, unless you fit into the politically correct mold, your right to speak, pray and associate with whom you chose are attacked and often denied by the courts. Activist judges are taking away our most basic American liberties by determining what words we may use to express ourselves; by denying the expression of religion (mostly Christian) in the public square; and by harassing groups like the Boy Scouts of America for upholding their moral beliefs.

ACRU Court Activity

Paulson v. City of San Diego

ACRU filed a brief in support of the City of San Diego in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit on an appeal by Paulson from a Federal judge’s order approving the sale of the Mt. Soledad property including the cross to a private association. The three judge Ninth Circuit panel affirmed the sale as valid, as the ACRU brief urged. But Plaintiff won a rehearing en banc by the entire 9th circuit which reversed and invalidated the sale on the grounds that it amounted to an unconstitutional establishment of religion under the California constitution. Read Brief

Paulson v. City of San Diego

ACRU filed a Petition for Writ of Certiorari in the U.S. Supreme Court on behalf of the private association which had bought the Mt. Soledad property in the sale invalidated by the Ninth circuit. But the Supreme Court denied the petition because the Ninth Circuit had invalidated the sale based on the California state constitution. Read Brief

Paulson v. City of San Diego

ACRU filed a brief in support of the City of San Diego in California state appellate court on appeal from a state judge’s order prohibiting the City from transferring the Mt. Soledad Memorial and its cross to the Federal government, as approved in a city referendum with 76% in support. The Federal government intervened to safeguard the monument by its powers of eminent domain; plaintiff Paulson is recently deceased. ACLU may file another suit challenging the Federal action. On January 12, 2007, the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals dismissed the lawsuit to remove the memorial as moot and said a district court order to remove the cross must be vacated. Read Brief

News & Commentary

10/26/07: Punishment will Hurt Community by Hans Zeiger

EXCERPT: "Almost 80 years ago, the City of Philadelphia granted to the local Boy Scouts a low-cost rent on land at 22d and Winter Streets, "in perpetuity." This has proven to be a valuable partnership, both for the city and for its most important youth organization. But last week, the city penalized the Boy Scouts for its membership policies by raising the rent from $1 to $200,000 a year. This was wrong..."

10/25/07: Failure of the First Amendment? by John Armor

EXCERPT: "This week, President Bush awarded the Medal of Honor to Lt. Murphy, handing that medal to his family, at the White House. Lt. Murphy was from Patchogue, N.Y., in the backyard of the New York Times. Yet the Times did not see fit to feature this extraordinary award to him and his family, on its front page..."

9/26/07: Marines Denied Right to Film in San Francisco

EXCERPT: "The US Marines proposed to shoot a recruiting commercial on the streets of San Francisco, as they already had on the streets of New York. They wanted their famed Silent Drill Team to perform for just a few minutes on ordinary city streets. New York said yes. But San Francisco said no..."

9/26/07: New Jersey Says Methodists Can't Be Methodists

EXCERPT: "The Ocean Grove Camp Ground was created and developed by the Methodist Church in the 19th century. At all times it has been owned and operated by the Methodists. For more than a century the Methodists have invited citizens of New Jersey, regardless of their religious beliefs, to share in the use of the property. Many people have asked for, and been granted, permission to conduct marriages on the property. However, it is the stated policy of the Methodist Church not to conduct same-sex ceremonies on its property..."

8/27/07: Using Courts as a Weapon Against America by John Armor

EXCERPT: "The supposedly anti-war group, A.N.S.W.E.R, has had the chutzpah to sue the District of Columbia for fining it for defacing city property with its posters. The group is claiming discrimination. The honesty of its claim can be gauged from the fact that one of its primary leaders is Ramsey Clark, the lawyer who claimed that Saddam Hussein was innocent, and being discriminated against..."

8/7/07: (CARTOON) "Hate Crime" vs. "Art" by Glenn McCoy

7/23/07: The Supreme Court Giveth, the Supreme Court Taketh Away by Ken Blackwell for Townhall.com

EXCERPT: "The Supreme Court teeters on a knife’s edge regarding lawsuits against faith expression in the public square. So, conservatives better redouble their efforts to restore a court faithful to our Founders’ vision, or lose all that has been gained in recent decisions after the 2008 presidential sweepstakes..."

7/16/07: Mosque & State are Fine – Just Shut Down the Church & State by John Armor

EXCERPT: "Investors Business Daily ran an editorial entitled, "Jihad in Schools," on July 9. It describes a program in a San Diego public school for setting aside 15 minutes a day for Somali Muslim students to pray at Carver Elementary School.... "

7/9/07: Lesbians Want Methodists to Allow Ceremony by John Armor

EXCERPT: "Two lesbians have brought a complaint against a park, owned and operated by the Methodist Church, for refusing them the "right" to have their civil ceremony (wedding?) in a pavilion there. The response of the Church is that it doesn't..."

7/9/07: CC Supreme Court to Hear Contentious Gay Rights Case by Mike McKee for Law.com

EXCERPT: "A war of the amici is under way as the California Supreme Court readies itself for what could become one of its most controversial cases in years... The case involves two San Diego-area doctors who, based on their Christian beliefs, refused to provide artificial insemination to a lesbian in their care. They claimed they weren't averse to treating gays, but rather had religious objections toward helping impregnate an unmarried woman..."

7/6/07: Religious Rights of Students Affirmed in NJ & TX from Citizenlink.com

EXCERPT: "A New Jersey school's decision to allow Christian students to enjoy the same free speech rights as other students could be the beginning of a nationwide trend to protect students' rights. Northern Highlands Regional High School had blocked a Christian club from participating in the Day of Truth, a day for Christian students to express their views on homosexuality, but backed down after being contacted by the Alliance Defense Fund (ADF)..."

11/5/07: Local court battle over protesting at soldiers' funeral begins, by Joe Dejka for the World Herald

EXCERPT: "Security was tight Monday as a Kansas woman appeared in Sarpy County Court to answer charges that she mutilated a flag and put her child in danger while protesting at the funeral of a..."

10/16/07: Opposing view: Press has enough protection, by John Armor

EXCERPT: "Reporters who choose to be martyrs don't warrant a federal law. Read more in USA Today here..."

6/24/07: The 'Study' on Conservative Talk Radio, by John Armor

EXCERPT: "The Center for American Progress is a liberal organization in its pedigree and staff. It has now released a "study" on the imbalance between conservative and "progressive" content on talk radio. It wants the government to compel a "balance" between..."

6/8/07: American Legion Steps Up Effort to Stop ACLU, by Sheldon Kinsel

EXCERPT: "As part of its effort to stop the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) from intimidating state and local governments to remove religious symbols from public places, the American Legion is organizing its local posts to inventory and monitor local memorials..."

6/1/07: May Crosses Be Displayed at War Memorials?

EXCERPT: "Two days ago I had the opportunity to do a radio debate with Dr. Jeremy Gunn, Director of the ACLU's Religious Freedom Project. Let me say at the outset that I found Dr. Gunn to be a courteous and intellectually..."

5/15/07: The ACLU Takes on James Madison and the Founders on School Prayer, by Eric F. Langborgh

EXERPT: "When James Madison penned the Bill of Rights in 1789, surely the idea of blocking local school children in Monroe, LA in 2007 from solemnizing their graduation ceremony with prayer was his intent, right? After all, he objected to official..."

5/15/07: Are Some Crime Victims More Worthy of Protection than Others?, by William G. Otis

EXERPT: "The Washington Post editorialized in its on-line edition yesterday in favor of the Hate Crimes bill recently passed by the House. The editorial is well wide of the mark, but in order to allow readers to draw their own conclusions..."

5/11/07: Hate Crimes: 'Solving' a Non-Existent Problem, by John Armor

EXERPT: "The House of Representatives has just passed a federal bill on "hate crimes," which seems headed for a White House veto, if it manages to pass the Senate. This has heightened attention to the half of the several states which..."

5/1/07: ACLU Gets It Dead Wrong in Indiana, by John Armor

EXERPT: "The ACLU in Indiana has just filed suit against the state's Bureau of Motor Vehicles on behalf of a tree-hugger who doesn't like religion. Does that sound unfair? Here are the facts, from an article in the Journal Times in... "

4/19/07: The ACLU's 'Hate Speech' Gymnastics, by Eric F. Langborgh

EXERPT: "The attorneys at the American Civil Liberties Union must be exhausted. It's not easy to contort one's reasoning in such a way that defends the Nazi's right to march while simultaneously supporting so-called hate crimes legislation. Perhaps a little consistency..."

4/11/07: Ninth Circuit Helps ACLU 'Cleanse' Library of Worship, by John Armor

EXERPT: "The facts, but not the legal conclusions, for this post come from an article on 23 March in the Washington Examiner by Quin Hilyer. It recited that the US Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco had just reversed..."

More Information

10/11/07: Spotlighting Speech Codes with FIRE’s Widget by Luke Sheahan

EXCERPT: "Over the last several years, the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (FIRE) has conducted a thorough survey of campus speech codes at over 350 American colleges and universities and compiled the data in one location on FIRE's website..."

9/11/07: Second Letter to Guilford School Board by Peter Ferrara

EXCERPT: "I am submitting these comments regarding the proposed rules concerning meetings of the Boy Scouts of America and other youth groups at Guilford County public schools, and communications regarding those meetings. I understand that the School Board has asked for comments regarding the proposed rules before its next meeting Thursday night, September 13..."

8/27/07: Open Letter to the Guilford School Board by Peter Ferrara

EXCERPT: "We understand that the Guilford County School Board will consider a couple of proposals relating to the Boy Scouts at its meeting this Thursday night, August 30. One proposal, allegedly based on safety concerns, would prohibit the Scouts and others from meeting in District schools during after school programs until 6 pm each night. The Scouts would have to hold any of their meetings at schools after 6pm..."

 

Review our
most recent
IRS Form 990 and
financial statements

The American Civil Rights Union
1600 Wilson Blvd, Suite #960
Arlington, VA 22209
703-807-0242   |   877-730-ACRU (2278)

   

Copyright 2007, American Civil Rights Union